Comcast and Cablevision lose appeal over channel sharing rules


Paul William Tenny

Coax cableComcast and a few other cable giants sued the FCC over a rule that prevents them from keeping regional sports channels (and other channels) that they own away from their competitors. They lost at the appellate level on Friday, and that's obviously good news for you if you happen to have something other than cable, or are even on a cable provider other than Comcast and Cablevision.

Those two companies complained that the rules were unfairly applied to them, but not DirecTV, a direct competitor. Comcast is right, the rule isn't being fairly applied to everyone. But that doesn't mean the rule should go away or that Comcast should get what it wants.

Just the opposite is true in fact, what should happen is that the rule should also be applied to DirecTV and everyone else. No service provider should be allowed to own a channel and keep it on their service exclusively. It may sound like unfair government interference in private business practices, but that's kind of the purpose of government -- to interfere on our behalf when companies aren't playing fair, hurting consumers and competition in the process.

This case will no doubt be appealed again to the same court for what's called an en banc hearing, but there's no requirement that the appeals court grant such an appeal. And it'll go to the Supreme Court, regardless, but there's no guarantee that they'll hear it either.

So whether or not you agree with the appropriateness of the ruling and the intent of the rule, this is definitely a win for consumers and a loss for Big Cable that wants to force you to subscribe to their service in order to get the channels that they themselves own. Even if they don't offer their service in your area at all.


in Business, Legal, Television
Leno is already struggling

Leno is back at the helm of The Tonight Show and he's already on the verge of losing to Letterman; Conan's rumored tour is set to begin in April.
Tagged: Conan O'Brien, David Letterman, Jay Leno, Tonight Show

Looky what I have

I have on my desk the next two un-aired episodes of Stargate Universe.
Tagged: Stargate Universe, SyFy

Ausiello's list of which TV shows are getting voted off the island

Michael Ausiello shares his list of shows that are coming back, on the bubble, and being buried as we speak.
Tagged:

Stephen King: When I heard about Leno's new show, my heart sank

Stephen King writes about how he's glad that the Jay Leno experiment failed, even though he likes Leno personally.
Tagged: Jay Leno, NBC, Stephen King

NBC probably violated Conan O'Brien's contact


Paul William Tenny

National Broadcasting CompanyI wanted to wait until I had something truly insightful to say about this, but a few days on and I've still got nothing. So here it is as plainly as I can say this: NBC violated Conan O'Brien's contract, and indisputably so. They would have lost any lawsuit and ended up paying out even more money than they already have. That's why O'Brien basically got the full value of his Tonight Show contract, because had he sued NBC, he would have gotten at least that much and probably a whole lot more.

Hollywood Reporter got the contract and confirmed what O'Brien's reps have been saying all along -- and what NBC has been lying about all along -- the Tonight Show was defined as a show starting at 11:35pm and the "second network series after the end of primetime".


Continue reading...
in Legal, Television
Google Buzz

You can follow me on Google buzz.
Tagged:

MGM is screwing Stargate fans

MGM is charging more for half a season of Stargate Universe on DVD than the most recent full season of House costs.
Tagged: DVD, MGM, Stargate

Michael Shanks is wrong - SG-1 is not dead

Michael Shanks thinks Stargate SG-1, even in the form of DVD movies, is dead. He's wrong.
Tagged: MGM, Michael Shanks, Stargate, Stargate SG-1

USA would be a good fit for Conan; forget HBO

Rumors abound and shallow hacks take cheap shots.
Tagged: Conan O'Brien

Done deal: Conan to leave with $32 million

Wire reports are saying that the deal for NBC to pay Conan O'Brien to surrender The Tonight Show and leave the network has been finalized.
Tagged: Conan O'Brien, NBC

View more stories by visiting the archives.

Media Pundit categories